India-Japan Bullet Train Project Stalled by Delays, Cost Overruns and Bitter Disagreements Over Equipment Procurement and Policy

Japan is relied upon to implement India’s first bullet train, with low-interest financing and modern technology, but the project has stalled due to delays and disagreements. More than a decade later, the two countries’ bitter differences have taken a public form in equipment procurement and policy conflicts, and as a result, the Mumbai-Ahmedabad high-speed rail line has yet to see the light of day. The 508-km railway line, which runs from Mumbai in Maharashtra to Ahmedabad in Gujarat, is a major initiative to modernise India’s rail network. In 2015, the two countries agreed to a Rs 980 billion deal, with Japan providing a 50-year loan at just 1.01 per cent interest. However, the initial target was to start operations in 2023, but that date has been pushed back. Work has repeatedly stalled due to land acquisition complications. According to government estimates, the estimated cost of the project has now risen to at least 1.87 trillion rupees.

Tensions have risen in recent months. Former Japanese Justice Minister Hideki Makihara wrote on X in July that the Indian side was entirely to blame for the lack of progress. He also commented that “they never keep their promises.” Japanese officials have alleged that India broke the terms of the agreement by awarding a key signaling system contract to German company Siemens, a rival of Japanese companies in the international market. Japanese companies led by JR East are said to be disappointed. Japan’s argument is that the entire system must be integrated to maintain the reliability, safety and punctuality of the bullet train. On the other hand, the hybrid system being developed, which combines Japanese railway lines, European signalling and Indian trains, has not been tested anywhere before. A Japanese source involved in the project said it has now become so chaotic that discussions have virtually reached a standstill. JR East, however, declined to comment on the matter.

In another sign of concern, Tokyo has created a new post in Japan’s foreign ministry to oversee the project. India, on the other hand, has indicated that it will build its own high-speed train, which will have a capacity equivalent to that of Japan’s desired train. A top official of the Railway Ministry, speaking on condition of anonymity, said that both sides are now in the same position. The decision was taken after detailed discussions and consensus. Modernization of the railway system is a major symbol for Narendra Modi’s government. It is part of the Make in India initiative, as well as modernizing the old network built during the British era. India has already electrified 99.6 percent of its broad-gauge railways, more than many European countries. The Indian-made semi-high-speed Vande Bharat train already runs on the Ahmedabad-Mumbai route. The railway ministry plans to build seven more high-speed corridors, totaling about 4,000 kilometers. It aims to attract 16 trillion rupees in investment. The government has said that Indian-made slow trains will start operating on at least 100 kilometers of the first phase next summer. Japanese diplomats, however, have said that the first phase will be only 50 kilometers and they are also skeptical about the timetable.

The two countries have different positions on technology and costs. Indian negotiators have prioritized local production, cost reduction and the opportunity to maintain independence in the future. Japan wants to keep the entire system as a unified package. The Indian side feels that a kind of superiority mentality has emerged in the Japanese behavior, which has irritated them. Japanese diplomats also admit that the introverted mentality of the country’s corporate sector towards the outside world has increased the distance between the two countries. A senior Japanese diplomat said, “The Japanese set realistic goals and execute them well. Indians set their goals much higher, and if not completely execute them, they execute them quite well.” The railway ministry official admitted that the construction of the first part of the project could be completed by early 2027. But the likely delivery date of Japan’s next-generation E10 train is the early 2030s, leaving a big gap between the two. The train will be able to travel at a maximum speed of 320 kilometers per hour.

But no matter how deep the dispute between the two countries is, maintaining India-Japan relations in the face of China’s growing influence is of great strategic importance. At a summit in New Delhi in July, Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi said the two countries should strengthen their ties “like brothers and sisters.” The joint statement said Japan fully understands India’s goal of launching a limited high-speed rail line next year. A senior Indian diplomat has said that the pace of bilateral relations between the two countries is now much faster than the pace of the high-speed rail project.

Hot this week

Topics

Related Articles

Popular Categories

Carrusel con Enlaces y Pausa al Hover (Corregido)
Carrusel con Enlaces y Pausa al Hover (Corregido)